Garfield's Train: Personal Presidential
History
Reviewed
by Lynda Ochsner
Garfield’s Train,
by Feather Schwartz Foster, brings an entertaining story, rooted in the
author’s expertise --U.S.
Presidents. About President Garfield
(1881), who was assassinated during the summer of his first term, the
story is
told in an interesting, informal manner, as a story-within-a-story.
Katharine Louise (“Kate”) is a
modern-day 79-year-old woman,
relating the story of a train trip with her maternal grandmother
(Louise
Dunbar) when she was 23 in 1947. She
accompanies her grandmother to see a dying friend, Mollie Brown. During the trip to California,
and again on the return trip, Gran tells the story of her own
upbringing and
relationship with her friend Mollie Brown during the late 1870s and
early 1880s
in New Jersey.
The Dunbar family live year-round in Long Branch, New Jersey, a summer
vacation home to the many famous and wealthy, including the Garfield
family. As Gran relates, Long Branch was the "Gilded Strand" of
the Gilded Age.
We soon learn that Mollie Brown’s maiden
name was Garfield,
and that she was
the daughter of President Garfield. From
this point, the story becomes even more exciting. Through
the double first-person narrative, we
get to know the various members of the Dunbar family and some details
about the Garfield
family. An early section of the book, in
which Gran names off all the various relatives in the Dunbar
family tree, is confusing and overwhelming—a visual family tree diagram
would
help. After a while, though, it becomes
clear that only a few of the many named characters are relevant to the
story; the reader can focus on that part
rather than try to keep up with the larger Dunbar
family
As with Foster’s previous book, First Ladies, this book includes excellent research and
attention
to historical details, including the political power structure of the
day. Other famous characters have a part,
including former President Grant and even Susan B. Anthony. Some narrative parts, where Louise tells what
she was aware of at age 13, seem rather unrealistic for the average
girl of
that age to recall – especially after “Gran’s” self-admission that she
really
had not been that knowledgeable of politics (and Kate notes the
contradiction,
too!). Yet the author also skillfully
inserts “notes” sections with additional material at various places:
material
that Kate gathered, either in 1947 or more recently.
Garfield’s Train
is another entertaining and educational historical novel from Feather
Schwartz
Foster. The historical material is
presented in a fun way, nothing like a dry history textbook, in a
rather short
novel (226 pages) that can be read quickly -or not so quickly-- and
enjoyed by all. The historical insights and trivia bring the
period alive--in all its glamour as well as political dirt-- to remind
us also how little some things have changed.
|